Texas Tribune: Misleading on Climate
By Sterling Burnett -- March 10, 2023“That all of these claims can be debunked with readily available data is a testament to the frailty of the current narrative on climate change. It’s a shame that so many journalists are willing to ignore the facts, fearmongering about climate change for political reasons, when in reality the data reveal there is more to fear from fear itself, not from climate change.”
A year ago, a Texas Tribune “Brief” listed seven alleged ways climate change is already impacting the state of Texas and its residents. When not outright false, the listed claims are extremely misleading. Yet María Méndez and Erin Douglas’s “Seven ways climate change is already hitting Texans” is not the first and will not be the last Tribune article piece which runs the gamut of common alarmist lines. And the short-term trends (weather) relied upon in the article–watch the bouncing ball.
Background
This isn’t the first time Erin Douglas and The Texas Tribune have published false information about the impacts of climate change on Texas. Just three months earlier, Climate Realism debunked another article where Douglas makes similar claims. Her claims about hurricanes (point two in this latest piece), droughts (point five), and extreme weather, including the counterintuitive fourth claim that cold snaps will increase in Texas due to warming, were not supported by existing data. Since dealing with those three specific claims, and since no new data has developed, the present response, with one exception, will address her new exaggerations.
First, Méndez and Douglas claim: “Texas is getting hotter — even at night.” Measured average global temperatures have risen modestly over the past century of warming, but claims that it is a dangerous or unprecedented rise are unsubstantiated. There is debate as to whether any temperature increase has occurred recently in the United States, as explained here. Indeed, as shown in the graphic below, data from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration indicate Texas is part of the region of the United States where average temperatures have been at or below average for the past 30 years.
The Texas Tribune is right that to the extent warming has been measured in Texas it is higher nighttime lows being recorded. However, this is not due to “global warming.” Rather, as explained in Climate at a Glance: U.S. Temperatures and Climate at a Glance: Urban Heat Islands, this measured nighttime rise in temperatures is due almost entirely to poorly sited temperature gauges in and around major cities. When temperature gauges are surrounded by concrete, next to buildings, or sited near artificial heat sources, the heat from the sunlight that the surroundings absorb during the day is slowly released or radiated back at night. This causes temperatures measured at these locations to be artificially high compared to temperatures measured in more rural Texas locations.
One short point on claim two, “Hurricanes that hit the Texas coast are getting more powerful,” is that the proof the writers give for increasing hurricane power comes from studies that allegedly show “[c]limate change increased the intensity of Hurricane Harvey in 2017.”
The studies referenced all use computer simulations to try to attribute some percentage of the rainfall during hurricanes to climate change. Attribution studies are prime examples of bad science, as discussed in detail in this Climate Realism post, where H. Sterling Burnett, Ph.D., explains how these simulations work and where they get their input data from.
Burnett writes:
That general circulation climate models have serious failings is widely known. There is a significant debate concerning what factors influence global temperatures, as well as, for any particular factor, what direction and to what extent they influence temperatures. Those who have developed climate models admit they don’t understand the role that clouds or large scale ocean circulation patterns play in driving climate change, for example.
In addition, real-world data demonstrate no statistically significant trend in hurricane frequency and overall a statistically significant decline in powerful hurricanes as discussed here, here, and here (also see the figure below). In short, the best evidence suggests the kinds of attribution studies referenced by the Texas Tribune lack supportable, much less definitive, data.
Their third point, “Sea levels are rising along the Texas Gulf coast,” is also unalarming. Sea levels are rising almost everywhere as is natural during interglacial periods. Present sea level rise is lower than experienced for most of the past 12,000 years since the earth emerged from the most recent ice age, as discussed here, here, and here.
There is no evidence that the rate of sea level rise in Texas has increased during the period of modest warming. Land subsidence, underground water withdrawals to slake the thirst of growing populations, and the draining of wetlands which tend to buffer the coast from storms and tides, account for the few locations in Texas where sea levels appear to be rising at a faster rate than the global average.
Skipping ahead to the sixth point, “The risk of illnesses is growing,” the writers say that insect-borne illnesses like malaria, West Nile virus, and other mosquito-borne illnesses typically associated with the tropics, will become more common. This is also false. Climate at a Glance: Malaria and Mosquito-Borne Diseases, shows that according to World Health Organization data, the number of malaria deaths have decreased by half since the year 2000. This has occurred alongside modest warming. Nor have there been any malaria deaths in North America since 1990.
Indeed, malaria was endemic in the United States through the 1950s, making thousands of people ill each year, until the country took public health measures to virtually wipe it out. Also, as pointed out in this Climate Realism article, here, there are a variety of other factors involved in the spread of mosquito-borne illness, such as the prevalence of standing water, bird migration, and the concentration of human dwellings. Climate change is not a significant factor.
The final point in the piece, “Climate change is driving more migration,” is another common but false refrain. In the context of Texas, most of the migration discussed comes from South America and Mexico. However, since extreme weather is not increasing in those countries, nor are crop yields suffering, there is little evidence to support the claim that climate change is responsible. Instead, other factors must again be considered.
On this point, during the summer of 2021 the President of Guatemala chastised Vice-President Kamala Harris when she was visiting his country for claiming the United States’ growing illegal immigration problem was due to climate change. He said the more welcoming attitude the Biden administration was displaying towards illegal immigrants than the previous Trump administration had was responsible for the surge in illegal immigration, not climate change.
Conclusion
That all of these claims can be debunked with readily available data is a testament to the frailty of the current narrative on climate change. It’s a shame that so many journalists are willing to ignore the facts, fearmongering about climate change for political reasons, when in reality the data reveal there is more to fear from fear itself, not from climate change.
————————–
This article, slightly revised, was published in ClimateRealism, a exaggeration-correcting website of the Heartland Institute. Linnea Lueken did research for and authored this article with Burnett. The points made in this article are a year better, and the Texas Tribune a year worse, in March 2023.