A Free-Market Energy Blog

Environmentalism or Individualism? (Part 6: The “Ideal” of Primitivism)

By Robert Bidinotto -- August 16, 2024

Ed. Note. This concludes our six-part series on the incompatibility of environmentalist ideology with the foundational individualist philosophy of the United States. Previous posts were “America’s Enlightenment Heritage” (Part 1); “Conservation vs. Preservation” (Part 2); “Inhuman Rights” (Part 3); “Philosophic Conflict” (Part 4); and “The Value of Nature” (Part 5).

“Environmentalism reflects an antipathy for a complex, technological, and free society where survival is bought at the cost of ambition, learning, thinking, taking risks, and working hard, within a free, competitive marketplace.”

Despite all the benefits of modernity, the primitive tribal “ideal” of self-denial still persists, most explicitly within the environmentalist movement.

Because of its enduring popularity, many view its environmentalist advocates as sincere idealists, but simply too extreme. Nothing could be further from the truth.…

Continue Reading

Environmentalism or Individualism? (Part 5: The Value of Nature)

By Robert Bidinotto -- August 15, 2024

Ed. Note: This is Part 5 on the ideology of environmentalism and its incompatibility with the foundational individualist philosophy of the United States. “America’s Enlightenment Heritage” (Part 1) is here; “Conservation vs. Preservation” (Part 2) is here; “Inhuman Rights” (Part 3) is here; “Philosophic Conflict” (Part 4) is here; “The ‘Ideal’ of Primitivism” (Part 6) is here.

“Yes, we too are part of nature; but our nature is that of a developer…. It’s morally appropriate for us to regard the rest of nature as our environment—as a bountiful palette and endless canvass for our creative works.”

The basic premise of preservationism is that all of nature—except, of course, human nature—has “intrinsic value” in itself, and thus a “right” not to be affected by Man.…

Continue Reading

Environmentalism or Individualism? (Part 4: Philosophic Conflict)

By Robert Bidinotto -- August 14, 2024

Ed. Note: This is Part 4 of a six-part series. “America’s Enlightenment Heritage” (Part 1) is here; “Conservation vs. Preservation” (Part 2) is here; “Inhuman Rights” (Part 3) is here; “The Value of Nature” (Part 5) is here; and “The ‘Ideal’ of Primitivism” (Part 6) is here.

“The fundamental concern of environmentalists is about the logical incompatibility of the values underlying a modern, technological, capitalist society, and the values embodied in the environmentalists’ image of Eden.”

Why, despite such transparent manipulations of fact and science, and their overt indifference to economics, have environmentalists been winning the battle for the hearts and minds of ordinary people?

Because they’ve never based their appeals primarily on facts, statistics, science, or economics. They rest their case ultimately on ethical and philosophical grounds.…

Continue Reading

Environmentalism or Individualism? (Part 3: Inhuman Rights)

By Robert Bidinotto -- August 13, 2024
Continue Reading

Environmentalism or Individualism? (Part 2: Conservation vs. Preservation)

By Robert Bidinotto -- August 12, 2024
Continue Reading

Environmentalism or Individualism? (Part 1: America’s Enlightenment Heritage)

By Robert Bidinotto -- August 9, 2024
Continue Reading

Houston: Oil and Gas Capital (‘energy transition’ hyperbole falls flat)

By Robert Bradley Jr. -- August 8, 2024
Continue Reading

“Psychedelics for Climate Action” (Tripping in Church of Climate)

By Robert Bradley Jr. -- August 7, 2024
Continue Reading

State of Alaska’s “Priority Climate Plan” (EPA bribe = trouble)

By -- August 6, 2024
Continue Reading

Energy & Environmental Review: August 5, 2024

By -- August 5, 2024
Continue Reading